We just didn’t vibe.
She has such a great vibe.
I really didn’t like his vibe.
We use the word vibe so often, but do we even know what it means?
The word vibe is short for vibration. Two things can each vibrate on their own, but when their vibrations meet, they affect each other.
In 1665, the Dutch scientist Christiaan Huygens was stuck in bed with a minor illness, with little to do but stare at two of the pendulum clocks he had invented, hanging side by side on the wall. He noticed something strange: no matter how the pendulums started, within about half an hour they swung in perfect opposition to each other, like mirror images.
He moved the clocks around and tried again, and eventually worked out what was happening. The clocks were hanging from the same wooden beam, and every swing sent a tiny, almost invisible movement through it to the other clock. On its own, each clock kept its own time. Hanging together, they couldn’t help affecting each other.
Huygens called it an odd kind of sympathy. Three and a half centuries later, we would probably just say the clocks vibed.
People, of course, aren’t pendulum clocks, and we don’t literally swing in sympathy with whoever happens to be hanging nearby. But it’s an interesting way to think about what happens when two people meet. We each have our own vibe, but what happens when we come together?
A Little Chemistry
Anyone who survived an eighth-grade science fair probably remembers the classic baking soda-and-vinegar volcano. Baking soda is a white powder that sits in the back of the fridge absorbing smells, and vinegar is something you put on salad. Put them together, though, and you get the volcano that half the grade proudly presented with a sign that said Chemical Reaction.
The fizz isn’t in the baking soda, and it isn’t in the vinegar either. And it doesn’t happen with just any two things. Pour water on baking soda, and all you get is wet baking soda.
People are considerably more complicated than household ingredients, but the psychiatrist Carl Jung thought the comparison held up surprisingly well. He said, “The meeting of two personalities is like the contact of two chemical substances: if there is any reaction, both are transformed.”
Three Dates, Three Different Men?
Suppose three women go out with the same man. Not simultaneously, obviously. That would be a different shidduch problem.
The first comes home and says he was funny, interesting, and so easy to be around. She hasn’t laughed that much on a date in ages. The second describes him as pleasant but rather serious. Not much of a sense of humor. The third finds him intimidating and has trouble relaxing around him.
All three women could be describing their dates quite accurately.
It’s the same guy, but each woman brings out a different side of him. And that’s really the difference between a personality and a vibe. Your personality is yours, but a vibe is something you create with someone else. It has less to do with what each of you is like on your own, and much more to do with what happens when you’re together.
Two Champions Don’t Always Win
Put two excellent tennis players on the same side of the net, and you might expect an unbeatable doubles team. Sometimes that’s exactly what you get. But sometimes they spend the whole game colliding at the net, both lunging for the same ball, or both leaving it for the other, each assuming the other has it covered. Pair each of them with someone else, and suddenly they’re playing beautifully again.
Neither one has forgotten how to play tennis. They just don’t play particularly well together.
On a tennis court, everyone understands that two great players don’t automatically make a great team. When it comes to a shidduch, though, we somehow expect two wonderful people to add up to a wonderful match.
Someone suggests a shidduch. He’s intelligent, responsible, and has great middos. She’s warm, thoughtful, easygoing, and has a terrific personality. Everyone agrees it’s a perfect match. The shadchan is already mentally spending her shadchanus. Then they go out, and the highlight of the evening is when he drops her off back home.
He’s every bit as nice as everyone said. So is she. But neither seems to bring out much personality in the other.
Some combinations simply won’t fizz, no matter how pleasant everyone is, and that’s fine
Two people can each have awesome personalities and still not particularly enjoy each other’s company. We can’t know that from references, resumes, or even the most detailed description of someone’s personality.
The only way to find out is to spend time together.
What Is a Vibe, Anyway?
If you’ve ever tried to explain to a shadchan why a perfectly lovely shidduch just didn’t work, but couldn’t put your finger on why, you may be comforted to know that scientists have had the same trouble.
Kelly Campbell, a psychologist, became curious about chemistry because of her own friends, who came from very different backgrounds and yet had clicked with her almost instantly. When she started asking people what creates that kind of connection, her hairdresser told her that you just have it with some people, which, as it turns out, isn’t far off from what the research found.
In one study, Campbell and her colleagues asked several hundred people to describe the chemistry they had felt with friends and with partners. Their answers came down to a handful of themes: being able to talk openly, enjoying each other’s company, feeling similar, warmth, and an instant sense of connection. Then there was one more category, which the researchers labeled, quite honestly, indescribable factors.
In an earlier study, she asked people who had never felt chemistry with a friend why they thought that was, and the most common answer was, “I really don’t know.”
So the people who have it can’t fully explain it, and the people who don’t have it can’t explain that either. After years of studying the subject, Campbell herself admitted she still wonders whether chemistry involves something science can’t measure. She simply doesn’t know.
A missing vibe isn’t a verdict on anyone. You can admire someone, appreciate every one of their wonderful qualities, understand exactly why their friends adore them, and still find that the fizz just isn’t there. That doesn’t make you too picky, and it doesn’t make them any less eligible.
Do Your Vibes Vibe?
If a vibe is something two people create together, why can one of them come home hoping for a second date while the other is already working out how to phrase a polite no to the shadchan?
Creating something together doesn’t mean experiencing it the same way. Two people can share a dish that one finds perfectly seasoned and the other finds a little too spicy, though nothing about the dish changed between bites. A vibe belongs to both of you, since neither could have produced it alone, but each of you feels it from your own side of the table.
So a “yes” from one side and a “no” from the other rarely means that someone misread the date. He really did enjoy himself, she really didn’t feel it, and neither of those facts cancels out the other.
Maybe we give people too much credit, and too much blame, for the vibes we feel around them. When we say, she has an amazing vibe, we may really mean that we love the way we are together. And when we say, I didn’t like his vibe, we may be saying our vibes didn’t mix.
So when a date doesn’t click, it doesn’t have to mean that one of you is the problem. He can be a catch, she can be a catch, and together they can still be a mismatch. Two tennis champions can lose a doubles match and still be champions, and baking soda and water can sit side by side all afternoon without producing a single bubble.
You can both have great vibes, but that doesn’t mean your vibes vibe.
Miriam
P.S. Wondering why your vibes never seem to vibe? An outside perspective can help you see what’s really happening on your dates.
If you’re interested in working with me one-on-one, you can read more about my coaching by clicking here: For first-time singles or second-time singles.