The Real Issue

A few days after having some routine bloodwork done, you notice a voicemail from your doctor’s office. The receptionist asks you to call back when you get a chance, but it’s already ten past five, and the office is closed for the day.

You listen to the message again, hoping for a clue about what the doctor wants. The receptionist sounds pleasant enough, but why couldn’t she have just said what the call was about?

You mention the message to a friend, who helpfully informs you that, in her experience, doctors don’t usually call unless there’s something to discuss. Thank you for that reassuring observation.

Suddenly you remember how tired you’ve been lately, the headache you had last week, and that strange pain in your shoulder that disappeared after approximately eleven seconds. You search online for information about the tests you had done, which leads you to several alarming medical conditions you hadn’t even known existed an hour earlier. By bedtime, you’ve diagnosed yourself with something dreadful.

The next morning, you call the office the moment it opens. The receptionist just wanted to know whether Thursday would work instead, because your doctor will be away the day of your follow-up appointment.

That’s it.

An entire evening spent worrying about a problem that didn’t exist.

The Dating Brain

Now put that same brain on a date.

Say you’ve been out three times with someone and it’s going well. The first two dates were almost four hours each, and the third ended after two and a half. You had a nice time, the conversation flowed, nothing felt off. So, the math ain’t mathing.

Was he bored? Did I say something? Did he look at his watch? Wait, does he even wear a watch?

By the time you get home, you’ve lined up all three dates side by side, comparing them as though there’s an official chart and two and a half hours means he’s losing interest. It doesn’t occur to you that he might have had an early morning, or been tired, or that the evening simply ran its course.

This nagging thought, at least, you came up with all on your own. Sometimes someone else is happy to plant the doubt for you…

The fourth date is five hours, so apparently he wasn’t bored after all, and you come home happy. You liked talking to him, you felt like yourself, and you’d say yes to a fifth date in a heartbeat. You tell your sister about the date, and she looks up from her phone and asks, “Doesn’t he seem a little immature to you?”

You hadn’t thought so. Honestly, his sense of humor was the best part of the night. But now you’re lying in bed replaying it.

Was that joke kind of childish? Is someone who’s serious about getting married supposed to be that goofy?

Anyway, one person’s immature is another person’s refreshing, and your sister isn’t the one dating him. You are. So you ignore her comment.

The More You Look, the More You See

By the fifth date, your sister’s comment has mostly worn off, and the evening is off to a good start. Somewhere between the main and dessert, Pesach comes up, and he mentions that his family doesn’t eat gebrokts. You laugh and tell him that in your house, the matzah balls are practically family, and the conversation moves on.

As you’re getting ready for bed, you picture your first Pesach together. Are you ready to give up your mother’s matzah balls forever? How would she feel about a son-in-law who won’t touch her kneidlach?

He said plenty of other things that night, too. He can’t stand cilantro, he’s been trying to learn to play guitar for three years, and he once got so lost in Yerushalayim that it took him four hours to find his way back. But all you can focus on is Pesach without gebrokts.

When the shadchan calls to ask about a sixth date, you say, “He’s a really great guy, but we have a matzah ball issue.“

There’s a pause on the other end of the line. “A matzah ball issue?“

Hearing it out loud, it sounds exactly like what it is. Making a mountain out of a molehill. Making an elephant out of a fly. Making an avalanche out of a snowflake. Blowing it all out of proportion. Much ado about nothing. Making a fuss over nothing. Turning a burnt piece of toast into a five-alarm fire, a pebble into a boulder. Pick whichever phrase you like, because they all mean the same thing: creating an issue where none existed.

Making Something Out of Nothing

The matzah ball issue is an exaggeration, and a deliberate one. I doubt anyone ends a shidduch over gebrokts, or admits to it. People do end them, though, over things that aren’t much bigger. He wore the same suit on two dates. She took ten minutes to decide what to order. He has a laugh that makes the whole room turn around. She ordered only a Diet Coke. Her family is a lot louder than yours.

If your coworker wore the same suit twice or your cousin took ten minutes to order, you wouldn’t give it a second thought. On a date, though, everything goes under a magnifying glass, and things you’d ignore anywhere else suddenly seem to mean something.

Once something catches your eye, it has a funny way of showing up everywhere. Say he takes the bridge instead of the tunnel, even though the tunnel would have been faster, and it crosses your mind that maybe he was avoiding the toll. Now you’re wondering whether he’s cheap, and on every date after that you’re keeping score. He ordered water, skipped dessert, and mentioned he got his coat on sale. What you don’t notice is that he paid for parking without a second thought, didn’t blink when you ordered the most expensive main on the menu, and left the waiter a generous tip.

Psychologists call this confirmation bias, which is a fancy way of saying you usually find exactly what you went looking for. Once you’ve decided he might be cheap, everything that fits that idea stands out, and everything that contradicts it gets ignored, until before long you’ve made an issue out of a toll.

Your brain loves to skip ahead. There’s a name for that too: catastrophizing, which is a dramatic word for something we all do. He mentions he likes to keep things simple, and you’re already imagining a wedding with three guests, a deli platter, and no band.

His family is a little loud, and you’re picturing every Shabbos for the next forty years with a headache.

He’s not a morning person, and you see years of doing every carpool while he sleeps through it.

He’s not into traveling, and suddenly you’re seventy, you’ve never left Flatbush, and only seen the Kosel in pictures.

And that’s exactly how a non-issue becomes an issue.

It’s amazing how much mileage we can get out of one little detail. Give it enough thought, throw in a few assumptions, and before long you’ve turned something tiny into a full-blown shidduch emergency.

Remember that voicemail from the doctor’s office? You turned a simple scheduling change into a life-threatening illness. All that worry, all those terrible possibilities, and the only thing waiting for you the next morning was a Thursday appointment.

We do exactly the same thing when dating. We notice one small thing, whether it’s something he said, something she did, or just a detail about a family or a habit, and off we go, making a whole production out of what it might mean. Before long, a small bump in the road becomes a roadblock, a hiccup becomes a catastrophe, and a whisper becomes a roar.

The problem is that by the time our imagination is through with it, it doesn’t feel small anymore. It feels like a serious enough issue that saying no seems like the only reasonable decision, when really, we’ve just made an issue out of a tissue.

Somewhere out there is a really great guy who didn’t get a sixth date because of a matzah ball issue.

Before you say no to someone, make sure your reason is bigger than a bowl of soup.

Miriam

Would you like to get a fresh perspective or help with clarity? If you’re interested in working with me one-on-one, you can read more about my coaching by clicking here: For first-time singles or second-time singles.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to our Email List

Stay in the loop! Get our top-notch dating and relationship advice straight to your inbox.